Historiography

The word ‘history’ originates from the Greek historia, meaning “inquiry, knowledge acquired by investigation”. It corresponds to the study of the past and throws light on various past events of significance which shaped and evolved human experiences.

The Historiography

Historiography is the study of the methods and criteria followed by historians in understanding and developing history as an academic discipline, and by extension is any body of historical work on a particular subject. The historiography of a specific topic shows how historians have studied that topic using particular sources, techniques, and theoretical approaches.

In other words, historiography can be understood as the writing of history based on the critical examination of sources and the selection of particulars from the authentic material. In the simplest form, Historiography is the art of writing history after collecting all related shreds of evidence and facts about a particular event that occurred in history.

The early colonial historians such as S James Mill, V.A. Smith, and HH Wilson emphasized that the knowledge of history writing was absent during the ancient age. It was emphasized that no historical work was composed in India before the Establishment of Turkish rule and Indians team the art of history writing from Turks.

Though Ancient India didn’t have great historians like Herodotus at the same time it’s not correct to say that knowledge of historiography was completely absent during the ancient age.

Puranas have the element of historical work because in these books the subject matter is classed into five parts. Puranas contain names of rulers and dynasties in a chronological manner. “Itihas Puranas” highlights the subject matter of history.

Puranas
Representational Image: The Puranas

Though chronological work was not found in most of the ancient works at the same time it should be emphasized that works like Vedas & Arthashastra, Nitisar & Harshacharita are important historical sources for understanding life in Ancient.

Kalhana can be termed as the 1st true historian as he wrote the complete history of Kashmir in the correct sequence. He was a native of Kashmir in the 12th Century AD. He wrote the book named “Rajatarangini”, in which he explained the various attributes of a true historian & true historical work.

The art of historiography witnessed remarkable progress in India during the Medieval age. This may be because of the art of history writing for more development in Persia & Central Asia who invaded and ruled India in that period. The rulers of the Delhi Sultanate maintained the court historians who were assigned the duty of compiling important details and events. Even though literary sources are quite scattered and unavailable but it will not be right to say that Ancient Indians were not aware of historiography completely.

Importance of Historiography

Historiography is considered important for a wide range of reasons.

  1. Historiography helps us to understand why historical events have been interpreted in various manners over different periods. In other words, historiography helps us examine not only history itself overlying characteristics that shape the recording of history itself.
  2. Historiography allows us to study history with critical thinking and help us to assert various logical reasons related to a historical event. It helps us understand what all possible biases may have shaped the historical record. It ensures we don’t blindly follow or believe what we read from various historians 10, 100, and 1,000 years ago. It ensures we don’t fall prey to these same mistakes some previous historians may have made either intentionally or unintentionally.
  3. For historians, the study of history is important for its details. How were social and economic factors such as income, census reports, and related numbers recorded, and by whom? Do they give an accurate representation of one social group’s poverty or not? Are the numbers, quite literally, fudged, or can they be trusted to reflect accurately the disparity between classes? These questions which need to ask time to understand our past resulted in various methods of writing history.
  4. We can say that historiography gives us an appreciation and motivation of how factors shape and alter the recording of history shape and alter our interpretation of it as a result.

While understanding the significance of Historiography, one must consider how history can be written, previous works of historiography, and schools of writings of history which we can find archaeological sources, literary sources, and School of writings. These sections will help aspirants to initiate the preparation of history for GS-1 (Prelims) and will also help to understand ancient Indian history. 

Previous Year Questions for UPSC Prelims

Ques 1: Consider the following statements regarding the Vedic literature available for reconstructing ancient Indian history:

I. Vedic literature, mainly the four Vedas i.e. Rik, Yajur, Sama, and Atharva Vedas, are entirely in a different language, which can be called the Vedic language.
II. The vocabulary of Vedic literature contains a wide range of meanings and at times different grammatical usages.
III. Six Vedangas (limbs of Vedas) were evolved for the proper understanding of the Vedas.

Which of the following statement(s) is/are correct?

a. Only I
b. I and II
c. II and III
d. All of the above

Answer: Option D

Explanation: Vedic literature, mainly the four Vedas i.e. Rik, Yajur, Sama, and Atharva Vedas, are entirely in a different language, which can be called the Vedic language. The vocabulary of Vedic literature contains a wide range of meanings and at times different grammatical usages. 

It has a definite mode of pronunciation in which emphasis changes the meaning entirely. This is the reason why an elaborate means to protect and preserve the mode of pronunciation of the Vedas has been devised. 

Six Vedangas (limbs of Vedas) were evolved for the proper understanding of the Vedas. These are Siksha (phonetics), Kalpa (rituals), Vyakarna (grammar), Nirukta (etymology), Chhanda (metrics), and Jyotisha (astronomy). Each Vedanga has developed credible literature around it which is in the sutra form i.e., precepts.

Ques 2: Which of the following statement is correct?

I. Panini’s Ashtadhyayi, a book on grammar in eight chapters is the final culmination of this excellent art of writing in sutra (precepts) in which every chapter is precisely interwoven.
II. The Brahmanas elaborate Vedic caste system of the society.
III. The Aranyakas and the Upanishads give discourses on different spiritual and philosophical problems.

Which of the following statement(s) is/are correct?

a. Only I
b. I and II
c. I and III
d. All of the above

Answer: Option C

Explanation: Panini’s Ashtadhyayi, a book on grammar in eight chapters is the final culmination of this excellent art of writing in sutra (precepts) in which every chapter is precisely interwoven. The Brahmanas elaborate Vedic rituals of the society. The Aranyakas and the Upanishads give discourses on different spiritual and philosophical problems.

Quick Questions on Histriography for UPSC Preparation

Historiography is the writing of history, particularly the writing of history that is based on the critical analysis of sources, the selection of specific details from the authentic materials in those sources, and the synthesis of those details into a narrative that withstands the test of critical analysis.

It is the examination of how, as a result of numerous causes, historical accounts and interpretations of the same events change over time. Understanding how sociological, political, economic, and other factors may affect how history is recorded over time is made easier by historiography.

The “father of history” has been referred to as Herodotus. He remained the primary source of original historical knowledge for not only Greece between 550 and 479 BCE but also for much of western Asia and Egypt at that period. He was an engaging narrator who had a keen interest in the customs of the people he described.

Four major schools of historiography have emerged in recent years as historians have studied India: Cambridge, Nationalist, Marxist, and Subaltern.

History is the study of a particular event or time period. The study of historiography examines how history was written, who wrote it, and what influences were at play when it was written.

History is the study of a particular event or time period. The study of historiography examines how history was written, who wrote it, and what influences were at play when it was written.

Share This:

Leave a Comment